
Thus far, we have performed a detailed value chain analysis, ISO self assessment audit, identified core social areas of focus, framed strategic social objectives, aligned them with business objectives and framed strategic solutions to accomplish / achieve the strategic social goals. The next step involves developing a business case.
But first let us answer what is a business case and why we require one? A business case is a rationale for any undertaking by a business. Such an undertaking can take many form. It can be a new strategic project to meet some business objectives, or social objectives or both. It can be an internal workflow assessment and improvement project or it can be an entire program such as social responsibility program consisting of number of individual projects. It can even be a new organizational policy (i.e. preferential treatment for local sellers – a new procurement policy) or regulation (i.e. new regulation to meet all the fire standards relevant to the business).
In our context, we will create business cases to substantiate and promote sustainable business practices. Such practices can take the forms of an entire program, projects, process improvements, policy and regulatory changes within the organization.
Business cases have a singular focus. They are financial assessment of the undertaking. To put it simply business cases are basically a cost and benefit analysis of an undertaking. If the benefits outweigh the cost for the undertaking, there is a higher likelihood that an undertaking will be approved by the top management. For sustainable business practices and social responsibility programs, the challenge lies in assessing the ‘full/whole cost and benefits’ from such practices and programs. Traditionally such cost benefit analysis took into consideration direct costs and benefits only.
For example, suppose a software developer company is considering setting up a computer lab in small government schools and training students in relevant applications as part of their social responsibility program. Some of the major direct costs associated with the projects will be computer hardware and software costs, employee time – measured in hours volunteered to the project. As for benefits, there are no direct financial benefits from the project. Rather the benefits are intangible in terms of goodwill generation amongst the locals, brand awareness and promotion, increased employee commitment and motivation etc. In the traditional methods such intangibles were either ignored or were acknowledged but were not monetized. As a result many of these projects never saw the light of the day. This is the case with majority of the sustainable business initiatives.
Social | Environmental | Economical |
---|---|---|
Who are the stakeholders and how are they impacted? | Does the initiative directly impact the environment | What is the total investment and how much of that is invested in clean technology |
This information can be obtained from the stakeholder analysis performed in the earlier stages. If an initiative impacts external stakeholders and if the impact is ??????? than a more detailed social benefit analysis is required | If the outcome of an initiative directly impacts the environment in terms of emissions, water usage, energy usage, bio diversity loss etc, than it is candidate for a more detailed environmental benefit analysis. | If the initiative requires substantial monetary investment than it is candidate for a more detailed economic benefit analysis. What constitutes substantial is upto the firm to decide. |
Example ::
Initiative | Social | Environmental | Economic |
---|---|---|---|
Initiative 1:
To promote adoption of health and safety rules of the health and environmental hazards posed by processing of raw materials and use of chemicals |
Stakeholder: Mine Workers Impact level: High Action: Perform SROI analysis. |
None | Total estimated investment: Rs. 45 Lakhs Action: perform economic benefit analysis |
Initiative 2:
Adopting High-Efficiency, Low-Emissions (HELE) Coal-Fired Power technologies |
Stakeholder: Coal plant operators Impact level: High Action: Perform SROI analysis. |
Stakeholder: Local environment and biodiversity Impact level: Moderate to high Action: Perform SROI analysis. |
Total estimated investment: Rs. 45 Lakhs Action: perform economic benefit analysis |
Initiative 3:
Devising new procurement policy giving preferential treatment to local suppliers (3 star hotel business). |
Stakeholder: Existing vendors of the company and local vendors (not currently supplying to the company). Impact level: High Action: Perform SROI analysis. |
Stakeholder: The environment (carbon footprint of supplies) Impact level: moderate Action: Perform SROI analysis. |
Total estimated investment: Rs. 45 Lakhs Action: Perform economic benefit analysis |
Initiative 4:
Set up training programs for workers to operate the new heavy duty diggers. |
Stakeholder: Machine operators Impact level: Moderate Action: SROI analysis not required. |
None | Total estimated investment: Rs. 5 Lakhs Action: SROI analysis not required |

Template A | Template B |
Template C | Template D |
Template E | Template F |
Template G |